The door did not lead into a dungeon.
It led into an Astern where another Elian had won.
Elian stepped through first and saw a city beneath a clear sky. The towers had been washed clean by rain. Flags without mourning colours dried on the rooftops. No executioners stood at the palace gates. Bread, cloth and apples were sold in the square, and nobody whispered about the collapse of the Drafts.
None of the places where Elian had died frightened him as much as this one. This city was beautiful.
Lissa walked beside him, tense but alive. Shani kept a little way behind, Miran studied the windows, and Tavel read the signs, afraid that every word had been written over someone else's name.
Another Elian Vern sat on this world's throne, unscarred and untouched by any of their present losses.
The very Elian whose face Nim wore. He looked like a man who had never once been made to pay for power. His hand bore no scar that had cost him ten years of life. There were no shadows beneath his eyes from deaths that he alone remembered. Even his ceremonial clothes sat easily on him, as though the crown had come to him through precise calculation, not through ash and blood.
Another Lissa stood beside the throne, smiling and remembering her brother. A jewelled clasp gleamed in her hair, probably a gift from Elian on the day of his coronation.
The Lissa who had come with them went still.
The unscarred Elian rose.
"Now you see," he said. "The world you are rejecting exists. And it is more merciful than yours."
Elian looked at the square beyond the windows.
"Where is Shani?"
The unscarred Elian smiled regretfully.
"There are many girls in the palace service."
"I asked for a name."
"You ask about the price, then pretend the price matters more than the result."
Miran stepped forward.
"Where is Miran Kest?"
"The northern records were declared false. The Kest line was not restored: that would have caused a dispute over land, and then a war. Thousands would have died."
Tavel asked quietly:
"And Tavel Rin?"
The unscarred Elian hesitated. That pause told Elian enough.
The hall of the unbroken world held great gilded books of bloodlines and laws. There were no empty shelves among them: every gap had been carefully concealed. The archive looked complete because no room had been left in it for the unrecognised.
The Lissa of the unbroken world went to her brother and took his hand.
"He saved me," she told the other Lissa. "He saved the country and became the king everyone had been waiting for."
The Lissa who had come with them gazed at her as though at a beautiful dream that belonged to someone else. There was no ash there, no knife on the table. She had never been forced to decide all over again whether her brother could be trusted: it was as though nothing terrible had ever happened to her.
The unscarred Elian took a step towards Elian.
"You decided that true salvation must always hurt. Suffering matters more to you now than saving anyone. I chose one world, one throne and one living sister. I closed the other Drafts and ended the Throne's hunger."
"You fed it."
"I gave it those whom this world did not remember anyway. The difference between us is that I do not make the living look every day upon those I failed to save."
The argument sounded reasonable, and that was precisely why Elian was afraid.
What if people truly could not bear to remember every loss, every day? What if a peaceful world with Lissa alive was better than endless attempts to bring back everyone who had vanished? What if Elian clung to names not out of kindness, but because he did not know how to say goodbye?
Savern entered the hall through a side door.
Not the Savern who had come with them, but the unscarred one. He bore none of the weariness of the old collapse. He stood calmly beside the throne. This Savern had won alongside Elian because he had found an heir prepared to accept the established order without question.
"Here is the world in which I was not mistaken," the unscarred Savern said.
Beyond the windows of the unbroken palace, a celebration began. The bells rang steadily, without alarm. Children ran after ribbons in the square, merchants laughed, and the guards let carts through without searching them. It could not be a mirage: the people smiled in earnest, the bread was warm, and the towers were reflected in the fountain's clear water.
And still Tavel went pale.
"There are no gaps in this world's archive," he said.
"Is that a bad thing?" the other Lissa asked.
Tavel ran a finger along the spine of the nearest book.
"It is if there were gaps, and instead of being filled, they were hidden."
Miran looked at the guards beyond the window. The men stood in neat, even ranks with identical spears. Not one of them bore a northern insignia.
"Nobody disputes anything here," she said. "Because those who disagreed were erased before anyone else had time to learn their names."
The Lissa who had come with them tightened her fingers around Shani's. She chose to hold on to the maid, though a happy and unharmed version of herself stood nearby.
Elian saw it and understood which world his sister had chosen.
Elian asked:
"Is Orm Hal alive?"
The unscarred Elian turned towards the window.
"A world has no need of an executioner after the correct execution."
The answer brought no comfort.
In this beautiful world nobody saw suffering because those who suffered had been struck out in advance. No one mourned Shani because no one knew her name. No one searched for Miran: every record of her had been destroyed. No one feared empty shelves: the archives had learnt to conceal their gaps.
Elian looked into his own unscarred face.
"You are not the me who won."
"Really?"
"You created a world paid for by people who had no right to object."
For the first time, the unscarred Elian stopped smiling.
"But you have already made this choice once," he said. "In one of the erased Drafts, you took the throne, saved Lissa and closed all the others. I am no outsider to you. I am the Elian who agreed to pay the price and won."
Open in the reader